19 new this week · 3,717 honest reviews · 203 author interviews · 200K+ readersAboutWrite for usContact
Science Fiction

Carl’s Doomsday Scenario

★★★★★ 4.0 / 5
6 min readReviewed 22 Nov 2026

The training levels are over. Now the network wants a season arc.

The verdict

Carl, Princess Donut and their raptor reach the Over City, a ruined volcano town of quests, elites and writers' rooms. Dinniman sharpens the satire of an audience that feeds on death and stages bigger, stranger set pieces. The opening is a long stat menu, the jokes recycle, and newcomers must start with book one.

As an Amazon Associate, The Bookish Elf earns from qualifying purchases.

Is it for you?
Read it if
  • You finished book one and wanted the satire sharpened.
  • You enjoy game mechanics as plot, with loot, levels and odd item descriptions.
  • Gallows humour that turns suddenly tender works for you.
Skip it if
  • Stat blocks and inventory lists bore you.
  • Gross-out jokes and constant swearing put you off.
  • You have not read the first book.

Barely a block into the third floor, trumpets blare out of nowhere, glitter spills across Carl’s vision and a quest title spins into place like the opening card of a TV special. Seconds later, skull-masked lemurs are throwing knives at his head. That is the bargain Carl’s Doomsday Scenario by Matt Dinniman makes from its first outing: every horror arrives with a production budget, and somebody, somewhere, is checking the ratings.

Carl’s Doomsday Scenario Plot Summary

Earth’s survivors have reached the third floor of the alien game show dungeon, and the first job is choosing a race and a class with their guide, Mordecai. Carl, a Coast Guard veteran with no trousers, and Princess Donut, his ex-girlfriend’s talking show cat, emerge into the Over City: a crater-sized set of small villages ringed by monster-filled ruins, safe by day, lethal by night, with eight days before the floor collapses. Quests now appear, and Mordecai warns them off every one. Carl ignores him. A haunted circus sits in the ruins, a skyfowl town keeps finding dead women in its alleys, and a talk-show booking waits at the end of the week.

The Third Floor Turns Up the Dial

Book one was a tutorial with a body count. This is where the series stops explaining its rules and starts bending them. The floor is roughly the size of Arizona, the timer is short, and the threats change category: Carl meets his first elites, one-of-a-kind characters with their own storylines, and his first city boss, a monster no crawler this season has survived.

The escalation in Carl’s Doomsday Scenario by Matt Dinniman is less about bigger monsters than about bigger systems. NPCs turn out to be bio-printed, owned property, their memories wiped each season. Quests drag Carl into problems he cannot punch, and his best moves become negotiations, bluffs and gambles with loot. The fight with Heather, a roller-skating circus bear, ends with a lottery ticket that pays out in strawberry custard, and the result is unexpectedly sad rather than funny. Dinniman keeps finding the grief under the gag.

Carl’s power curve climbs too. His class leans on explosives and dirty tricks, Donut’s leans on charm and chance, and their pet velociraptor Mongo grows from a squawking chick into something genuinely frightening. A new party member, Katia, arrives late and changes the team’s shape. By the last act, Carl’s Doomsday Scenario by Matt Dinniman is juggling a mystery, a heist and a disaster at once, and it lands all three.

Everyone Is Watching, and Someone Is Writing

The counter-thread, and the reason this sequel outdoes its predecessor, is the satire of the audience. Mordecai explains that elites are characters in scripted serials, with writers and producers who will patch new instructions into their heads rather than let a crawler wreck a promising show. They carry heavy plot armor, and crawlers are the guest stars. Carl’s response, cutting a deal with the producers of a show called Vengeance of the Daughter through his agent Zev, is the smartest thing he has done so far, and the funniest.

The rest of the media machine gets the same treatment. Viewers vote on the contents of fan boxes, and trolls rig the result to hurt him. Sponsors are already placing early bids for the fourth floor. A live talk show, all celebrity panellists and audience call-ins, turns Carl’s on-air defiance into a political incident with real casualties, and Carl watches the galaxy mourn one famous guest after cheering the destruction of his planet. Carl’s Doomsday Scenario by Matt Dinniman is angriest here, and the anger gives the jokes weight.

Where It Gives Ground

  • The opening is a menu. The first two chapters are mostly race and class descriptions with stat lines; if you skim the blocks, little is lost.
  • Gags recycle. Catchphrases return chapter after chapter, and the joke about Carl’s magic boxers forbidding trousers outstays its welcome.
  • Lectures stall the pace. Plant-parasite biology, city-elf theology and a late villain’s rambling backstory each run longer than they need to.
  • Tonal whiplash. A child maimed by Mongo is played as farce only pages before a genuinely grim horror scene.
  • Crude humour is constant. If book one’s toilet jokes grated, nothing here will change your mind.

Where Carl’s Doomsday Scenario Sits in the Series

Carl’s Doomsday Scenario by Matt Dinniman is the second of eight books so far. Start with book one; the opening chapters here assume you know who Mordecai, Zev and Odette are and why Carl walks barefoot.

  • Dungeon Crawler Carl (#1, 2020)
  • Carl’s Doomsday Scenario (#2, 2021), the one reviewed here
  • The Dungeon Anarchist’s Cookbook (#3, 2021)
  • The Gate of the Feral Gods (#4, 2021)
  • The Butcher’s Masquerade (#5, 2022)
  • The Eye of the Bedlam Bride (#6, 2023)
  • This Inevitable Ruin (#7, 2024)
  • A Parade of Horribles (#8, 2026)

The gaps between books shrank to months in 2021 and grew after that.

Do You Need the Earlier Books?

Yes. Carl’s Doomsday Scenario by Matt Dinniman picks up shortly after book one ends, and the first scene reveals where the survivors stand without much recap. The rules of the crawl, Donut’s royal tiara and Carl’s feud with an orc prince all carry over. Read Dungeon Crawler Carl first; this one rewards the investment.

Read These Next

  1. Catching Fire by Suzanne Collins: another second book where a televised death game learns to fear its stars.
  2. Operation Bounce House by Matt Dinniman: the author’s later standalone, with colonists, mechs and a streaming audience.
  3. Monsters of Ohio by John Scalzi: comic science fiction that never forgets the bodies.
  4. The Running Man by Stephen King (as Richard Bachman): the bleak ancestor of every deadly game show.

Matt Dinniman and the Road to Carl’s Doomsday Scenario

Dinniman lives in Gig Harbor, Washington, and wrote Dungeon Crawler Carl in public, serialising it chapter by chapter on Royal Road, a web fiction platform, before self-publishing on Amazon. Carl’s Doomsday Scenario by Matt Dinniman first appeared as a Dandy House ebook in January 2021, only months after book one; Ace reissued the series in 2024. Before this series he wrote Kaiju: Battlefield Surgeon and the Dominion of Blades books.

  • Penguin Random House picked up the print rights in 2024 while Dinniman kept the ebooks.
  • The first eight books had sold more than fourteen million copies by July 2026.
  • A live-action series is in development at Peacock with Seth MacFarlane’s Fuzzy Door.
  • The author’s note at the back promised book three by April 2021; it arrived in March, and book four followed that June.

The Verdict

Carl’s Doomsday Scenario by Matt Dinniman is the book where the series finds its target. The dungeon is still a meat grinder, but the real monster is the audience, and Carl has started to work out how to play it. Push past the menus and the recycled jokes and you get a bigger, angrier and stranger story than book one. The galaxy is watching. Carl has decided to give it a show it will regret.

Content notes tap to reveal
Graphic gore, decapitations and exploding bodiesParasitic worms and body horror, including infestation of the narratorMurdered sex workers whose bodies are displayed and dumpedA child badly injured, played for dark comedySelf-harm for tactical reasons (a deliberately broken finger, self-poisoning)Heavy drinking by a mentor figure; drug referencesGrief for family and an ex-partner presumed deadConstant profanityHeat level: none on the page; brothel jokes and a magical charm effect played for laughs

Where to read Carl’s Doomsday Scenario

Amazon lists the current Kindle, print and audiobook editions, and shows whether the ebook is in Kindle Unlimited right now.

To borrow it free, try your library: Libby and OverDrive lend ebooks and audiobooks with a library card, and WorldCat finds print copies near you.

We don’t link to “free PDF” sites. Those copies are pirated and pay the author nothing.

More from Ace

See all →

You might also like

Latest reviews

All reviews →

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here