25 new this week · 3,682 honest reviews · 203 author interviews · 200K+ readersAboutWrite for usContact
Fantasy

Our Dark Incantations

★★★★★ 4.0 / 5
6 min readReviewed 21 Oct 2026

She came to be healed. The school handed her the wrong magic.

The verdict

A war healer sorted into the wrong institute at Ivercrest is bargained into a secret inquiry into Wielders dying of natural causes. The magic has real costs, the case gives the first half a spine and the healer heroine is genuinely capable. The last act piles on reversals, the villains flip too fast and the prose leans on repeated tics.

Trigger warnings & spice level
4/5 · Steamy

Open door, with several fully explicit scenes from about two-fifths in, some rough and possessive.

Show 12 content warnings may contain spoilers
TortureGraphic ViolenceChild AbuseSelf-HarmDeath of a ParentPTSDPanic AttacksForced SedationMemory ManipulationDrug UseAlcohol UseChronic Pain
Full content notes ↓

As an Amazon Associate, The Bookish Elf earns from qualifying purchases.

Is it for you?
Read it if
  • You want a dark academia romance with an actual murder case underneath it.
  • You like a morally grey, possessive hero and a heroine who heals instead of hiding.
  • Trauma written as a lived condition, nightmares and panic attacks included, is a draw rather than a deterrent.
Skip it if
  • Explicit sex is a dealbreaker or you prefer a slow, closed-door burn.
  • Plot twists that undo themselves within a chapter or two frustrate you.
  • You want a lean book; this one runs long and feels it.

The entrance test at Ivercrest University is a performance. Prospective Casters walk to the front of a domed hall one by one and show off a shield, a potion, a healed frog. Mira Winters, who spent the war closing wounds in her parents’ clinic, asks for a corpse. Two assistants wheel one in with a chest wound that is still bleeding long after death, because cuts made with Dark Magic never stop on their own. She seals it in minutes. Then something grabs her wrist, slams her to the floor, and when she gets up the Caster benches are empty, the candles are out, and the Highmage of Dark Magic is congratulating her on her admission. Our Dark Incantations by Wanda Hellmund spends its opening chapter making that switch feel like a trapdoor, and it is the best possible hook.

The novel, out now from Ace, is a debut, and it arrives as a full-length dark academia romantasy of more than five hundred pages.

How Ivercrest Divides Its Magic

The world runs on a hard split. Casters hold White Magic, which can shield and heal but never harm, and draws on the earth so it never runs dry. Wielders hold Dark Magic, carry a moving brand called the Shadowflame on the right hand, and can burn themselves out and die from overuse. A Wielder strengthens that power by gaining up to five signifiers, inked one per finger: control, pain, spirits, internum and sin. Mira has the brand and not one signifier, which makes her the joke of every combat class.

She has a reason to stay. A poison called Synth killed her parents during the war and left a scar on her arm that still burns, and she believes only Ivercrest’s ingredients can remove it. When Highmage Obryn catches her brewing with black-market supplies, he offers a bargain instead of expulsion: help a five-signifier heir named Aidric Dawson work out why former soldiers of the defeated tyrant Mercer keep dying of heart attacks. That inquiry, built around a locator potion she designed for her own scar, is the frame of Our Dark Incantations by Wanda Hellmund for its first half.

The Case Behind Our Dark Incantations

What the structure does well is make every clue cost Mira something. To test her potion she must spend nights in Dawson’s private lab. To trace an ingredient she must attend a council ball on his arm and break into an archive. And to keep up with him she must use the Dark Magic she has sworn off, and each new mark on her fingers lands as a small defeat. The mystery and the romance are the same machine here, and for roughly two hundred pages Our Dark Incantations by Wanda Hellmund runs beautifully, with each scene moving the case and the relationship forward at once.

What works

  • A heroine whose skills matter. Mira runs diagnostics, cleans wounds and improvises potions under pressure, and her medical eye solves problems the fighters cannot.
  • Magic with a bill attached. Overspending Dark Magic shows on the body as blackened veins and a fading brand, and borrowed power has side effects that linger for chapters.
  • Set pieces with real shape. The ball and archive heist, a Feeder demon released in a training cage, and an illegal auction under Triphea that ends in a rooftop chase are all clearly staged and genuinely tense.
  • Obryn and Amelia. The gruff Highmage who refuses to call anything impossible, and Amelia’s mock rulebook for Wielders, give the cast a dry wit the leads sometimes lack.

Where Our Dark Incantations Gives Ground

  • The last act will not stop. Once the central secret of Our Dark Incantations by Wanda Hellmund is out, the story stacks one apparent loss on another, and a stretch after the main climax re-covers ground readers already know.
  • The hero is described on a loop. His eyes, his breath, his jaw and his smirk return so often that the repetition starts to blunt the menace.
  • Convenient tools. A do-anything protective potion and a house that literally drops answers into Mira’s hands solve problems the plot should have made her earn.
  • Villains who switch too fast. The council stays faceless, and at least one antagonist turns cartoonish the moment the story needs a fight.

Read These Next

If Our Dark Incantations by Wanda Hellmund leaves you wanting more magic schools with blood on the floor, start here.

  1. Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarros, for a deadly school, a heroine who survives on brains rather than brawn and a dangerous rival turned lover.
  2. Ninth House by Leigh Bardugo, for campus magic wrapped around a murder and a heroine haunted by her past.
  3. The Atlas Six by Olivie Blake, for academic rivalry and power that corrupts the people chasing it.
  4. Under the Iron Sky by A.T. Emerald, from a writer who praised this book, for more enemies-to-lovers tension in a militarised world.
  5. Powerless by Lauren Roberts, for a heroine without the right gift pitted against a lethal heir.

New to the genre? Our guide to what dark academia is explains why the gothic campus keeps drawing readers, and the dark academia aesthetic itself has a long history online.

Find it, and 27 more, in our roundup of dark academia books for Halloween.

About Wanda Hellmund

Hellmund studied politics in London before moving to New York for a master’s degree in journalism at Columbia University, and that reporter’s training shows in how tidily she lays out the clues in the opening half. Our Dark Incantations by Wanda Hellmund is her first novel, and nothing in it hints at a sequel: the ending is closed.

  • Published by Ace as a 528-page hardcover, with an audiobook running close to fifteen hours.
  • Library Journal gave it a starred review ahead of publication.
  • A.T. Emerald, whose fantasy we have reviewed, and Lauren Kate both lent it early praise.
  • It is a standalone, so there is no reading order to worry about.

The Verdict

At its best, Our Dark Incantations by Wanda Hellmund is a detective story told by a medic who keeps getting dragged into the fight, and that combination gives it a texture the crowded field rarely manages. The first half is tight, clever and properly hot. The second half wants every emotional beat twice, and the book is longer than its story.

Readers who forgive excess for intensity will race through it. Everyone else will still remember the trapdoor on page one.

Content notes tap to reveal
Graphic violence, torture and on-page killings, some at close quartersDeath of parents (backstory) and recurring nightmares of itPTSD, panic attacks, self-harm by scratching, chronic painHeavy drinking and use of narcotic potionsMemory erasure without consent, restraint and forced sedationChild abuse and coercion in the hero’s pastHeat level: open door, with several fully explicit scenes from about two-fifths of the way in, some rough and possessive

Where to read Our Dark Incantations

Amazon lists the current Kindle, print and audiobook editions, and shows whether the ebook is in Kindle Unlimited right now.

To borrow it free, try your library: Libby and OverDrive lend ebooks and audiobooks with a library card, and WorldCat finds print copies near you.

We don’t link to “free PDF” sites. Those copies are pirated and pay the author nothing.

More from Ace

See all →

You might also like

Latest reviews

All reviews →

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here