16 new this week · 3,687 honest reviews · 203 author interviews · 200K+ readersAboutWrite for usContact
Home / Book Reviews / Fiction / Supernatural
Genre · 37 reviews

Supernatural

37 Supernatural reviews on The Bookish Elf. Supernatural here most often crosses with Paranormal, Horror and Mystery Thriller. The authors we review most are Stephen King and V.E. Schwab.

The 10 best Supernatural books we’ve reviewed

Ranked by our score
01
Smiling Faceless WomanThomas J Gebhardt III · 2025

As Thomas J. Gebhardt III's third novel—following Washington and Everyday Rainbows—Smiling Faceless Woman represents a confident leap into supernatural thriller territory while maintaining the character-driven focus evident in his previous work.

5.0★
02
Talisman – SubterfugeAaron Ryan · 2025

Talisman: Subterfuge announces Aaron Ryan's ambition to expand beyond his already impressive Dissonance series into something even more narratively complex and thematically rich. This opening volume successfully establishes a protagonist worth following through whatever…

5.0★
03
The Graveyard BookNeil Gaiman · 2008

An orphaned toddler is adopted by the ghosts of a hilltop cemetery and grows up learning the skills of the dead while his family's killer keeps hunting. Gaiman's linked-story structure gives every chapter its…

4.5★
04
The ExorcistWilliam Peter Blatty · 1971

Blatty builds his possession story like a case file, sending a frightened mother through neurologists, psychiatrists and a homicide detective before a doubting Jesuit is asked to help. The method makes the horror feel…

4.5★
05
Soul’s DespairVivek Bhanot · 2022

When a book attempts to combine reality and the supernatural, sometimes one or the other suffers in the process. However, Vivek Bhanot produced some mysterious and frightening supernatural elements that felt intriguing. This is a promising and…

4.5★
06
Interview with the VampireAnne Rice · 1976

Rice turns the vampire into a confessor, and Louis's two-century account of guilt, hunger and a child who can never grow up is lush, sad and often frightening. Lestat steals every scene he is…

4.0★
07
CarrieStephen King · 1974

King's debut assembles a bullied girl's prom night from inquiry transcripts, academic studies and wire reports, so the reader knows the destination long before anyone in town. The structure and the mother-daughter horror are…

4.0★
08
Pet SemataryStephen King · 1983

A young doctor, his wife, their two small children and the cat settle beside a Maine highway, and a kind neighbour shares a secret he should have kept. King writes family life so warmly…

4.0★
09
Salem’s LotStephen King · 1975

King drops a centuries-old vampire into a 1975 Maine town and builds the horror from timetables, gossip and sunsets. The hour-by-hour town chapters, the boy hero and the slow logic of the spread are…

4.0★
10
The Haunting of Paynes HollowKelley Armstrong · 2025

The Haunting of Paynes Hollow succeeds as both supernatural horror and psychological drama, offering readers a story that operates effectively on multiple levels. Armstrong's mature approach to trauma, family secrets, and moral responsibility creates…

4.0★

Frequently asked questions

What are the best Supernatural books The Bookish Elf has reviewed?
Which Supernatural authors do you review most?
How many Supernatural books have you reviewed?

37 so far.