14 new this week · 3,706 honest reviews · 203 author interviews · 200K+ readersAboutWrite for usContact
Book list · 20 books

Best Greek Mythology Retellings Like Circe and The Song of Achilles

Twenty Greek mythology retellings for readers who loved Circe and The Song of Achilles, sorted by what you actually want next: the voice, the romance, the rage or the scholarship.

20 books11 reviewed by us4.0 our avg rating
A
adminUpdated 9 Oct 2026 · 4 min read
Best Greek Mythology Retellings Like Circe and The Song of Achilles

Madeline Miller did not invent Greek mythology retellings, but she did change their economics. Circe took a minor witch from Book Ten of The Odyssey and turned her into a bestseller, and The Song of Achilles turned a schoolroom tragedy into a book people cry about on the bus. Every publisher in the English-speaking world took notes. Eight years later the shelf is crowded, and the quality varies wildly.

The current surge is film-driven. In the week of 3 August 2026, Publishers Weekly reported Circe up 128 per cent and The Song of Achilles up 82 per cent, riding the wake of Nolan’s Odyssey. If you have just finished one of them and want the same feeling again, the honest answer is that no single book delivers all of it. So this list of Greek mythology retellings is sorted by what you are actually chasing.

0/20
How many have you read?Tick “I’ve read it” on each book. Saved in your browser, no account needed.

Greek Mythology Retellings for the Voice

The thing people miss most about Circe is the narration: a first-person immortal watching centuries pass, wry and lonely and slowly accumulating power.

01
Ithaca by Claire North

Ithaca

by Claire North

Hera narrates a kingdom running on Penelope’s nerve while the king is away. The closest anyone has come to Miller’s register, and more politically astute.

02
Hera by Jennifer Saint

Hera

by Jennifer Saint · 2024
A Queen's Quest for Power and Purpose

The queen of the gods across the full sweep of the myths, furious and constrained. Saint’s most ambitious book.

04
Lavinia by Ursula K. Le Guin

Lavinia

From the Aeneid rather than Homer, and quietly the best-written book on this entire list. Le Guin gives a woman with no lines in Virgil a full interior life.

Greek Mythology Retellings for the Rage

Some readers came to Circe for the anger rather than the melancholy: the sense of a story finally being told by the person it was done to.

05
A Thousand Ships by Natalie Haynes

A Thousand Ships

by Natalie Haynes

The Trojan War through its women, from queens to captives, structured as a chorus rather than a plot. Sharp, funny and merciless.

06
The Silence of the Girls by Pat Barker

The Silence of the Girls

by Pat Barker

Briseis narrates the Iliad. The bleakest and most serious book here, and the one least interested in making myth beautiful.

07
The Penelopiad by Margaret Atwood

The Penelopiad

Penelope and twelve hanged maids, in barely 200 pages. It has lost none of its bite.

Greek Mythology Retellings for the Romance

The Song of Achilles readers are looking for something specific, and it is not scholarship.

If You Want the Whole Pantheon

Sometimes the problem is not that you want another novel. Plenty of readers come to Greek mythology retellings and discover the real obstacle is that they cannot remember who Tiresias is.

16
Stone Blind by Natalie Haynes

Stone Blind

by Natalie Haynes

Medusa again, but Haynes is a classicist and it shows in the detail.

Retellings Beyond the Greek Myths

The Greek shelf is not the only shelf, and the technique travels.

17
Cleopatra by Saara El-Arifi

Cleopatra

by Saara El-Arifi · 2026
Saara El-Arifi Gives Voice to History's Most Misunderstood Woman in This Mythic Retelling

Egypt rather than Greece, same appetite for a woman written out of her own story.

18
The Wolf Den by Elodie Harper

The Wolf Den

by Elodie Harper

Roman rather than mythological, set in a Pompeii brothel, and one of the most gripping historical series of recent years.

19
Kaikeyi by Vaishnavi Patel

Kaikeyi

by Vaishnavi Patel

The same revisionist move applied to the Ramayana, and done with real conviction.

20
The Witch’s Heart by Genevieve Gornichec

The Witch’s Heart

by Genevieve Gornichec

Norse rather than Greek, following Loki’s wife Angrboda. The nearest thing to Circe’s exact emotional shape outside the Mediterranean.

How to Choose in Ten Seconds

Five routes through the Greek mythology retellings above, depending on what you are chasing:

  1. Loved the loneliness of Circe: Ithaca, then Lavinia.
  2. Loved the ending of The Song of Achilles: The Silence of the Girls, then A Thousand Ships.
  3. Want the myth without the melancholy: Mythos, then Heroes.
  4. Want a romance first and a myth second: This Immortal Heart, then Bonds of Hercules.
  5. Want to leave Greece entirely: The Witch’s Heart, then Kaikeyi.

Reading the Originals Alongside

Greek mythology retellings work better when you know what they are pushing against, and the source material is free. The Perseus Digital Library hosts Homer, Hesiod and the tragedians in Greek with parallel English, which is the quickest way to check what a novelist has invented. For a poet who has spent forty years doing what these novelists do, turn to the 2026 Nobel laureate: our guide to Anne Carson’s Nobel Prize suggests which of her books to read first, starting with the Geryon myth retold as Autobiography of Red. If you would rather read a proper modern translation, our guide to choosing an Odyssey translation covers the ten that matter, and our list of books to read before Nolan’s film narrows the field further.

The Last Word on Greek Mythology Retellings

The form has been declared exhausted roughly once a year since 2018, and it keeps refusing to die, because the raw material was built for exactly this. These stories survived three thousand years by being retold, revised and argued with, and every writer here is doing what Homer’s audiences did: taking a story everyone already knows and asking who has not been allowed to speak yet. The good ones make the originals feel larger. The very good ones, like Circe, send you back to the source with your guard down.

All 20 books at a glance

#BookAuthorYearOur rating
01IthacaClaire North——
02HeraJennifer Saint2024★★★★★4.0
03I, MedusaAyana Gray2025★★★★★4.5
04LaviniaUrsula K. Le Guin——
05A Thousand ShipsNatalie Haynes——
06The Silence of the GirlsPat Barker——
07The PenelopiadMargaret Atwood——
08Those Fatal FlowersShannon Ives2025★★★★★3.5
09This Immortal HeartJennifer Saint2026★★★★★4.0
10The Things Gods BreakAbigail Owen2025★★★★★4.0
11Bonds of HerculesJasmine Mas2025★★★★★4.0
12Wearing the LionJohn Wiswell2025★★★★★4.0
13MythosStephen Fry2017★★★★★4.0
14HeroesStephen Fry2018★★★★★4.0
15Troy and OdysseyStephen Fry2020★★★★★4.5
16Stone BlindNatalie Haynes——
17CleopatraSaara El-Arifi2026★★★★★4.0
18The Wolf DenElodie Harper——
19KaikeyiVaishnavi Patel——
20The Witch’s HeartGenevieve Gornichec——

Keep reading

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here