14 new this week · 3,700 honest reviews · 203 author interviews · 200K+ readersAboutWrite for usContact
History

Bloody Broadway Volume II

★★★★★ 5.0 / 5
6 min readReviewed 16 Nov 2026

Every corpse had an opening night. Most had a closing notice.

The verdict

Kabatchnik catalogues 88 plays of murder and menace staged between 1930 and 1960, giving each a full synopsis, cast and run, the verdicts of the New York critics, later revivals and a playwright biography. The care spent on forgotten flops is the book's distinction. A fine resource for theatre people and mystery readers.

As an Amazon Associate, The Bookish Elf earns from qualifying purchases.

Is it for you?
Read it if
  • You direct, teach or programme plays and want casting, run and rights information in one place.
  • You read Golden Age mysteries and are curious how the same tricks played on a stage.
  • You research Broadway or film history and need dated review sources.
  • You enjoy browsing: any entry can be read alone in ten minutes.
Skip it if
  • You want a narrative history with an argument carried from chapter to chapter.
  • You plan to see or read these plays unspoiled. The synopses give away every ending and every culprit, by design.
  • You want the play scripts themselves. This is a guide to them, not an anthology.
Bloody Broadway — reading order

In August 1931 a play opened at the Avon Theatre in which all three acts began at 10:50 p.m. The first showed the ground-floor hall of a Park Avenue townhouse during a dance, the second the landing above it, the third the banker’s study on the top floor, so the audience heard the same gunshot three times and understood it only on the last. Three Times the Hour ran for twenty-three performances and vanished. Bloody Broadway Volume II by Amnon Kabatchnik gives it six pages, walks through each floor in turn, and notes that the script can be consulted at the Academy’s film library in Beverly Hills. That is the book in miniature: a patient record of what the crime play was doing on stage, kept by someone who thinks the failures matter.

Bloody Broadway Volume II Summary: What the Book Holds

Published by BearManor Media in 2026, Bloody Broadway Volume II by Amnon Kabatchnik is the second volume of a survey subtitled Plays of Menace, Murder, and Mystery; Volume I covered 1900 to 1930. The 532 pages hold 88 entries in order of first performance. Seventy-four are Broadway productions, running from John Wexley’s death-row drama The Last Mile (1930) to Gore Vidal’s convention thriller The Best Man (1960). A second section of fourteen follows plays that opened in Europe and later reached New York, among them An Inspector Calls, No Exit, The Maids and The Visit. A four-page introduction traces the form from William Gillette’s Sherlock Holmes onward. Musicals count too: Guys and Dolls, West Side Story and Redhead all qualify.

How an Entry Is Built

Each entry follows the same order. First comes a hook, usually the source novel or the real case behind the play. Then a synopsis, act by act, with enough stage business that you can picture the set. Then the opening date, theatre, director and cast, the verdicts of the New York dailies sorted into admirers and “naysayers”, the length of the run, the London transfer, revivals, films and television versions. A biography of the playwright follows, and the entry ends on two lines a working theatre will value: who publishes the acting edition, and what the play won.

The footnotes do real work. Nearly every critic’s line carries its newspaper and date, which turns the book into a finding aid for anyone who wants the full notice. A few notes wander off agreeably: the twenty-five titles Wexley considered before settling on The Last Mile are listed in full.

What the Long Runs Hide

The famous plays are here and well served. Arsenic and Old Lace gets its 1,444 performances, its curtain call of thirteen actors playing the cellar’s corpses, and a 1942 staging by students of Gallaudet that the author calls Broadway’s first sign-language performance. The thesis of Bloody Broadway Volume II by Amnon Kabatchnik, though, lives in the short entries. The Locked Room lasted eight performances, Little Shot four, Merely Murder three, and each is summarised with the same care as The Crucible. Kabatchnik’s “Dear Reader” note says he hopes to revive interest in neglected playwrights, and the method backs the hope: a director hunting for an unfamiliar thriller can judge one from these pages.

He also writes as someone who has staged this material. He mentions directing Winterset off Broadway in 1966, and a footnote explains what he did with the wheelchair in his own production of The Little Foxes. His judgements are brief and unsentimental. Of Graham Greene’s religious mystery he writes, “The passage of time has not been kind to The Potting Shed.” An overwrought 1934 shocker with an early Humphrey Bogart role is defended as “the kind of fun generated by a B movie gone haywire.”

What Bloody Broadway Volume II does well

  • The selection is generous. Charlie Chan’s single Broadway outing, Ayn Rand’s courtroom play with a jury drawn from the audience, and a Georgette Heyer adaptation sit beside O’Neill, Hellman and Miller.
  • Production history reads as story. Billy Budd survived because a producer with no stake in it paid for a newspaper advertisement praising it. The Andersonville Trial had Southern bookings cancelled for fear of protests.
  • Flops are measured, not mocked. Run lengths are always given, and a short run is treated as a fact to explain.
  • Adaptations are tracked. Films, remakes, operas and television versions follow each play, which makes Bloody Broadway Volume II by Amnon Kabatchnik useful to film researchers as well.

About Amnon Kabatchnik

The author is a retired theatre professor and director. His note in the book says he studied at Boston University and the Yale School of Drama, belonged to the directors’ unit at the Actors Studio, and taught at SUNY Binghamton, Stanford, Ohio State, Florida State and Elmira College. The dedication names Tyrone Guthrie and Lee Strasberg among his mentors. Bloody Broadway Volume II by Amnon Kabatchnik draws on decades of the same research.

  • His Blood on the Stage series, begun in 2008, catalogues crime plays by period.
  • Sherlock Holmes on the Stage (2008) does the same for the detective’s theatrical career.
  • Horror on the Stage and Courtroom Dramas on the Stage both appeared in 2023.
  • He has directed Arsenic and Old Lace twice, in Florida and New Hampshire.

Read These Next

  1. Bloody Broadway Volume I by the same author, covering 1900 to 1930 and the melodramas this volume grows out of.
  2. Our literary analysis of Of Mice and Men, the novel Steinbeck wrote alongside the play that has an entry here.
  3. The Turn of the Screw by Henry James, the source of The Innocents, whose 1950 staging the book covers in detail.
  4. Black Coffee by Agatha Christie, a stage whodunit in novel form, for the drawing-room tradition these plays worked in.
  5. Burning Bright by John Steinbeck, written as both novel and play; Kabatchnik records its thirteen Broadway performances.

What Stays With You

Winterset, Maxwell Anderson’s verse tragedy, won the first New York Drama Critics’ Circle award, and it is easy to see why a book like this would lead with such titles. What lingers instead is the company they keep. A reader comes away knowing that Jack Dempsey sat on a stage jury in 1935, that a locked-room puzzle with three causes of death closed after eight performances, and that West Side Story was first imagined as a Catholic and Jewish story set at Easter and Passover. Bloody Broadway Volume II by Amnon Kabatchnik treats a theatre season as it was lived, hits and casualties together, and the casualties turn out to be the better company.

The scripts are still out there. This book tells you where.

Content notes tap to reveal
Period slurs quoted from the plays, including racist and antisemitic language. The author states that he left them unedited for historical context.Murder in every entry, with executions, lynch mobs and prison violence in severalRape and sexual coercion in a number of synopses, including Johnny Belinda and RashomonSuicide, and the death of children in Bad Seed and The InnocentsOlder attitudes to homosexuality, disability and mental illness, reported as the plays and their critics voiced them

Where to read Bloody Broadway Volume II

Amazon lists the current Kindle, print and audiobook editions, and shows whether the ebook is in Kindle Unlimited right now.

To borrow it free, try your library: Libby and OverDrive lend ebooks and audiobooks with a library card, and WorldCat finds print copies near you.

We don’t link to “free PDF” sites. Those copies are pirated and pay the author nothing.

You might also like

Latest reviews

All reviews →

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here