Why we’re excited
Six college friends once starred in Fayerweather Friends, a homemade YouTube series with a devoted cult audience. Then one of them died, and the survivors spent twelve years guarding separate pieces of that night while the killer walked free. Now a stranger holding proof has come for them, and the old cast must decide how their story ends.
McManus built a large following with young adult mysteries such as Two Can Keep a Secret and the Bayview books, and this standalone is her first thriller written for adults. Readers who like reunion mysteries built on a group's shared guilt, The Secret History being the classic, should keep it in view.
On our most-anticipated list since 7 November 2026. See all the most anticipated books →
What to know about Dying to Be Us
Such Charming Liars is the one Karen M. McManus book we have reviewed, at 4 out of 5.
It sits at No. 21 on our May 2027 most-anticipated list, which ranks the month's books by how many readers have saved them.
From the publisher
Karen M. McManus, the #1 New York Times bestselling author of One of Us Is Lying, is back with her first novel for adults: a thriller about a group of former college friends bound for life by a murder that continues to haunt them.
Jeremiah Brody, the guy next door.
Genevieve Frost, the It Girl.
Pax Patel, the handsome heir.
Becca Yun, the drama queen.
Aly Wright, the scholarship student.
Finn McDougal, the aspiring filmmaker.
Twelve years ago, they were the stars of Fayerweather Friends, a cult-favorite YouTube show created by Finn. Everyone wanted to be them.
Until one of them died.
None of the Friends knows the whole truth, only the role they each played that night. For more than a decade, they have kept one another's secrets. And a killer went free.
But someone’s been waiting…someone who has evidence that could destroy them all.
If the show taught the cast anything, though, it's that they control their own stories, even the endings.
Because the truth is what you make it.
Description supplied by the publisher.
We haven’t read Dying to Be Us yet. When our review goes up, it will replace this page.




