Home / Series / Theo & Cynthie

Theo & Cynthie

The Theo & Cynthie series in reading order: 2 books reviewed on The Bookish Elf, first published between 2024 and 2025.

Book 1 in one line: Under Your Spell succeeds brilliantly as both a rock star romance and a story about healing from past trauma. Wood has created characters who feel like real people rather than romance archetypes, set against a backdrop that enhances rather than…

Books reviewed2

Series average4.0★

Where to start

Book 1Under Your Spell2024 · ★ 4.0

A Fresh Take on Rock Star Romance with Genuine Emotional Depth

Read our review of Under Your Spell →

Start hereUnder Your Spell2024 · ★ 4.0

A Fresh Take on Rock Star Romance with Genuine Emotional Depth

LatestLet’s Make a Scene2025 · ★ 4.0

A Masterful Exploration of Love, Trust, and Second Chances

Frequently asked questions

What is the reading order of the Theo & Cynthie series?

Under Your Spell, Let’s Make a Scene.

Where should I start the Theo & Cynthie series?

Start with Under Your Spell, first published in 2024.

The Bookish Elf

About us

The Bookish Elf is your single, trusted, daily source for all the news, ideas and richness of literary life. The Bookish Elf is a site you can rely on for book reviews, author interviews, book recommendations, and all things books.

Contact us: [email protected]

Quick Links

Reap & Sow by Charlotte B. Plumb

Fantasy October 10, 2026 0

A spoiler-free review of Reap & Sow by Charlotte B. Plumb: three siblings who pay off their dead father's demonic debt by selling strangers to the mirror in their cellar, ten years short of freedom with the harvest closing in.

Hallowed Bones by Lucy Smoke

Fantasy October 10, 2026 0

An orphaned eighteen-year-old arrives at a decaying college outside Salem and learns that four wealthy heirs are the last of a cursed coven, and that she may be the female witch they have waited three centuries for. Atmospheric, sexy and cleverly built, with a mystery that barely moves.

Sweet Thursday by John Steinbeck

Literary Fiction October 10, 2026 0

A sequel in which the sardines are gone, the canneries are silent, and Doc cannot work out what is wrong with him. It opens with a character from the previous book complaining about how that book was written, and then does everything he asks.