DeAndra Davis’s debut novel All the Noise at Once arrives as both a much-needed story and a masterfully crafted exploration of identity, family, and systemic injustice. This young adult novel weaves together the complexities of autism, police brutality, and racial profiling through the lens of teenage Aiden Wright, whose world revolves around two constants: his star quarterback brother Brandon and his love for football.
The Story That Unfolds
The narrative begins with Aiden’s desperate desire to join his high school football team, driven by both his genuine love for the game and his need to connect with Brandon before his brother graduates. When a spot opens up on the team, Aiden finally gets his chance—only to face resistance from teammates who question whether someone with autism belongs on the field.
What starts as a high school sports story quickly transforms into something much deeper and more urgent. A post-game altercation spirals into a police encounter that leaves Brandon arrested and facing felony charges for assaulting an officer—charges that threaten to destroy his football scholarship and future. As Aiden grapples with guilt and searches for answers, he must navigate both his own neurodivergence and the harsh realities of being Black in America.
Characters That Breathe
Davis crafts characters with remarkable depth and nuance. Aiden’s narrative voice is perhaps the novel’s greatest strength—his internal monologue feels authentic without falling into stereotypical portrayals of autism. His “NOTES” throughout the text provide both comic relief and genuine insight into how his brain processes the world around him.
Brandon emerges as more than just the “perfect” older brother; he’s a complex young man carrying the weight of expectations while fiercely protecting his younger brother. The supporting cast, from Isabella (Aiden’s budding romantic interest) to Marcia (whose decision ultimately impacts everything), feels fully realized rather than merely functional.
Writing That Captures Voice
Davis employs a straightforward prose style that perfectly matches Aiden’s perspective. The author’s background as an educator shines through in her careful attention to representing autism authentically. She avoids the twin pitfalls of over-explanation and patronization, instead allowing readers to experience the world through Aiden’s unique lens.
The dialogue crackles with authenticity, particularly in the brothers’ interactions. Their running game of random facts (“Did you know tiger pee smells like buttered popcorn?”) becomes a touchstone of normalcy in increasingly chaotic circumstances.
Tackling Complex Themes
The Intersection of Race and Neurodivergence
Davis boldly addresses what it means to be Black and autistic in America—a perspective rarely seen in young adult literature. She doesn’t shy away from examining how Aiden’s autism, combined with his race, creates additional layers of vulnerability during police encounters. The novel’s exploration of how systemic racism intersects with ableism feels both timely and necessary.
Police Brutality and Justice
The portrayal of Brandon’s arrest and subsequent legal battle is handled with careful nuance. Davis doesn’t paint all police officers with the same brush, yet she doesn’t soften the impact of police violence either. The video evidence plotline and Marcia’s father’s involvement add layers that examine complicity, privilege, and the courage required to do what’s right.
Brotherhood and Sacrifice
At its heart, this is a story about brotherhood—the fierce love between Aiden and Brandon, the sacrifices they make for each other, and the price of protection. As Aiden gains independence and finds his own voice, the dynamic between the brothers evolves in believable and touching ways.
Where It Succeeds
The novel’s greatest strengths lie in its:
- Authentic representation of autism without resorting to savant stereotypes
- Unflinching examination of racial profiling and police brutality
- Complex character development that avoids simplistic hero/villain dynamics
- Effective pacing that builds tension while allowing for character growth
- Skillful balance between serious themes and moments of genuine humor
Areas for Improvement
While All the Noise at Once succeeds on multiple levels, it occasionally struggles with:
- Information dumps during courtroom scenes that slow narrative momentum
- Some secondary characters who feel underdeveloped (particularly Georgia and Louis)
- Predictable plot developments particularly regarding the video evidence
- Slightly rushed resolution that doesn’t fully explore the aftermath of the trial
Cultural Impact and Relevance
All the Noise at Once arrives at a crucial time when conversations about police reform, racial justice, and neurodiversity representation are at the forefront of national discourse. Davis manages to address these heavy topics without preaching, instead letting the story and characters speak for themselves.
The book’s portrayal of West Gate—a predominantly white, affluent community—and the Wright family’s navigation of it offers sharp commentary on how location and socioeconomic status intersect with but don’t negate the dangers of being Black in America.
Who Should Read This
All the Noise at Once will resonate with:
- Young readers seeking diverse, authentic representation
- Educators and parents looking for literature that addresses contemporary social issues
- Book clubs wanting to discuss intersection of identity, justice, and family
- Anyone who appreciates nuanced character development and timely themes
Final Verdict
DeAndra Davis has written a debut that matters. All the Noise at Once doesn’t just tell a story—it amplifies voices that are too often silenced or misrepresented in young adult literature. While the novel isn’t perfect (some plot conveniences and pacing issues prevent it from achieving true greatness), it succeeds brilliantly in its primary mission: making readers see and understand perspectives they might otherwise never encounter.
The book reflects its solid execution and important themes, though readers should be aware that some plot elements feel slightly formulaic. Davis has created something genuinely valuable—a story that will make readers laugh, cry, and most importantly, think.
For readers seeking similar stories that blend social justice themes with compelling characters, consider The Hate U Give by Angie Thomas, On the Come Up by the same author, or Black Brother, Black Brother by Jewell Parker Rhodes. However, none of these specifically address the intersection of autism and race that makes Davis’s novel unique.
Looking Forward
As DeAndra Davis’s debut, All the Noise at Once sets high expectations for her future work. The author’s ability to tackle difficult subjects while maintaining narrative momentum suggests a writer with the potential to become a significant voice in young adult literature.
In a literary landscape often criticized for its lack of authentic diverse voices, Davis has contributed something genuinely needed: a story that refuses to simplify complex identities or reduce its characters to their struggles. Instead, she’s given us Aiden and Brandon Wright—brothers whose story will stay with readers long after the final page is turned.
