Marie Lu’s transition from young adult fiction to adult fantasy feels as seamless as alchemy itself in Red City, the first installment in The New Alchemists series. Best known for her dystopian Legend trilogy and the dark fantasy of The Young Elites, Lu demonstrates remarkable artistic evolution in this contemporary fantasy that transforms the familiar framework of organized crime into something altogether more magical and devastating.
Set in an alternate Los Angeles reimagined as Angel City, Red City presents a world where alchemy isn’t relegated to medieval manuscripts but thrives as the backbone of modern organized crime. The city belongs to two rival syndicates: Grand Central and Lumines, who control the production and distribution of “sand”—a drug derived from the philosopher’s stone that temporarily perfects whoever consumes it, making them more beautiful, charismatic, and capable than they could ever be naturally.
The Heart of the Matter: Sam and Ari’s Divided Loyalties
The narrative centers on Sam Lang and Ari Varga, childhood friends whose paths diverged when they were secretly recruited by opposing syndicates. Sam, desperate to escape poverty and provide for her injured mother, joins Grand Central under the tutelage of Will Constantine, the enigmatic and dangerous son of syndicate leader Diamond Taylor. Ari, taken from his family in India as a boy, becomes a rising star in Lumines under the harsh training of Mr. Rudra.
Lu excels at crafting these dual protagonists, allowing readers to witness their transformation from innocent teenagers exchanging letters about trees and dreams into hardened alchemists capable of transmuting matter with their souls. The alternating perspectives create a fascinating tension as we watch Sam and Ari navigate their respective organizations, each unaware of the other’s involvement until a fateful reunion five years later.
Sam emerges as perhaps Lu’s most complex protagonist to date. Her journey from invisible girl to feared alchemist nicknamed “Mozart” reflects Lu’s own understanding of how desperation can drive moral compromise. The author draws from personal experience with poverty to create authentic stakes for Sam’s choices. Her relationship with Will Constantine is particularly well-developed—a dangerous dance between attraction and manipulation that never feels simple or comfortable.
Ari’s arc as a reluctant Lumines operative wrestling with duty versus conscience provides excellent counterbalance. His struggle between loyalty to the organization that gave him purpose and his lingering feelings for Sam creates genuine emotional complexity. Lu avoids easy answers, showing how both characters have been shaped by systems that simultaneously saved and corrupted them.
The Seductive Brutality of Lu’s World-Building
The magic system deserves particular praise for its originality and consequences. Unlike traditional fantasy where magic comes freely, alchemy in Lu’s world demands payment in soul fragments. Each transmutation tears pieces from the alchemist’s essence, creating a haunting parallel to addiction and exploitation. The more powerful the alchemy, the greater the spiritual cost, until senior alchemists become hollow shells of their former selves.
This system brilliantly mirrors the real-world costs of organized crime while adding supernatural stakes. Characters must literally sacrifice parts of themselves for power, making every magical moment feel weighted with consequences. The syndicates’ treatment of their members as both valuable assets and disposable tools becomes more chilling when viewed through this lens.
Lu’s Los Angeles transformation feels both familiar and alien. The city’s existing inequality and glamour provide perfect soil for her vision of syndicate-controlled districts, underground alchemy schools, and the glittering Red City compound where Grand Central conducts its business. The author’s understanding of Los Angeles geography and culture shines through, making Angel City feel like a natural evolution rather than an artificial construction.
Sophisticated Themes Beyond Good and Evil
Where Red City by Marie Lu truly succeeds is in its refusal to provide simple moral frameworks. Both syndicates commit horrible acts while also providing opportunity and family to their members. Diamond Taylor emerges as a fascinating antagonist—simultaneously a protective mother and ruthless crime boss whose empire was built on horrific experimentation with her own son. Will Constantine becomes equally complex, revealing layers of trauma and genuine emotion beneath his calculated cruelty.
Red City by Marie Lu explores themes of survival, ambition, and the prices we pay for transformation with remarkable nuance. Sam’s arc particularly examines how circumstances can push someone toward choices they never imagined making. Her discovery that Will murdered her mother creates one of the book’s most powerful emotional beats, forcing her to confront how thoroughly she’s been manipulated while questioning whether her own actions make her complicit in the system she once despised.
Lu also weaves in commentary about perfection, privilege, and the industries built on manufacturing desire. The sand trade serves as metaphor for how society creates and exploits insecurities, offering temporary solutions that ultimately cause more harm than healing. The wealthy clients who consume sand for enhanced beauty or performance remain blissfully unaware of the human cost, a pointed observation about real-world luxury markets.
Craftsmanship in Character and Prose
Lu’s writing style has matured significantly for adult audiences while retaining the propulsive pacing that made her young adult work so compelling. Her prose balances elegant description with sharp dialogue, creating distinct voices for each character. The alternating perspectives never feel repetitive, as each narrator brings different insights and blind spots to events.
The romantic elements between Sam and Ari avoid typical fantasy romance tropes, feeling earned rather than inevitable. Their relationship carries the weight of shared history, betrayal, and the impossibility of their circumstances. Lu handles their reconnection with restraint, allowing emotional beats to build naturally rather than forcing passion where survival instincts should dominate.
Secondary characters like Sebastian, Diamond’s other lieutenant who specializes in violence as art, and Isla, Ari’s fellow Lumines operative, feel fully realized rather than functional. Each syndicate develops its own culture and hierarchy that readers can understand and navigate, making the world feel lived-in rather than constructed purely for plot purposes.
Minor Concerns in an Otherwise Stellar Debut
The novel’s length occasionally works against it, with some middle sections feeling slightly padded during the characters’ separate development phases. A few plot threads, particularly around the police investigation into syndicate activities, could have been streamlined to maintain better pacing. Additionally, some readers might find the violence description more graphic than expected, though it serves the story’s themes about the cost of power.
The ending sets up future installments effectively but leaves several key character arcs unresolved in ways that might frustrate readers seeking more closure. However, these concerns feel minor against the novel’s substantial achievements in world-building and character development.
The Verdict: A Transformative Reading Experience
Red City by Marie Lu succeeds brilliantly as both crime thriller and fantasy epic, offering readers the addictive plotting of organized crime fiction enhanced by magical elements that feel fresh and consequential. Lu has created a world where power comes at genuine cost, where loyalty and betrayal intertwine inextricably, and where love might not be enough to overcome the systems that shaped its protagonists.
For readers seeking fantasy that engages with real-world issues while delivering spectacular magical conflicts, Red City provides exactly what its title promises: a place where ambition and blood intermingle, where transformation comes through sacrifice, and where the pursuit of perfection reveals the beautiful darkness at the heart of human desire.
Key Highlights:
- Innovative magic system with genuine consequences
- Complex protagonists with authentic motivations
- Sophisticated exploration of power, loyalty, and moral compromise
- Excellent world-building that enhances rather than overwhelms the story
- Mature themes handled with nuance and restraint
If You Enjoyed Red City, Try These Similar Books:
- The Poppy War by R.F. Kuang – Military fantasy with dark themes and moral complexity
- The Priory of the Orange Tree by Samantha Shannon – Epic fantasy with multiple POV characters
- The Ten Thousand Doors of January by Alix E. Harrow – Portal fantasy with beautiful prose
- The Power by Naomi Alderman – Speculative fiction exploring power dynamics
- Mexican Gothic by Silvia Moreno-Garcia – Gothic fantasy with atmospheric world-building
- The City of Brass by S.A. Chakraborty – Middle Eastern fantasy with political intrigue
- Jade City by Fonda Lee – Urban fantasy crime saga with magical martial arts
