The Velvet Hammer by Chief Judge Belvin Perry, Jr. and Amy Mitchell

A Gripping Journey Through Florida’s Most Notorious Capital Murder Cases

In the sweltering heat of a Florida courtroom, where the air hangs heavy with tension and the weight of life-or-death decisions, sits a man who has seen it all. Chief Judge Belvin Perry, Jr. has presided over some of the Sunshine State’s most gruesome and headline-grabbing murder trials. Now, in his gripping memoir, The Velvet Hammer, co-authored with Amy Mitchell, Perry pulls back the curtain on his quarter-century career on the bench, offering readers a rare and unflinching look at the American justice system in action.

From Segregation to the Judge’s Chamber

Perry’s journey from a young African American boy growing up in the segregated South to becoming one of Florida’s most respected jurists is nothing short of remarkable. The son of one of Orlando’s first black police officers, Perry witnessed firsthand the slow, painful progress of civil rights in America. His accounts of childhood experiences—like tasting his first hot dog at a newly desegregated Woolworth’s lunch counter—are both poignant and illuminating.

But it’s Perry’s legal career that forms the meat of this engrossing true crime memoir. As a prosecutor, he tackled some of Florida’s most heinous criminals, including the notorious “Black Widow” Judy Buenoano, who poisoned her husband and drowned her disabled son for insurance money. Perry’s recollections of exhuming bodies and the nauseating stench of decomposition are not for the faint of heart, but they lend an undeniable authenticity to his narratives.

The Gavel Falls: Perry’s Most Infamous Cases

Perry doesn’t shy away from the controversial aspects of capital punishment. He candidly discusses the weight of sentencing eight people to death during his tenure, describing the sleepless nights and moral wrestling that accompanied each decision. His detailed accounts of these cases—from the savage quadruple murder committed by Jerry Correll to the disturbing crimes of Scott Mansfield, dubbed the “lust murderer”—are both horrifying and captivating.

But it’s Perry’s insider perspective on the infamous Casey Anthony trial that will likely draw many readers to this book. As the presiding judge in what he calls the “trial of the century,” Perry offers unique insights into the case that captivated the nation. His frustrations with the antics of both the prosecution and defense teams are palpable, and his assessment of the controversial verdict is both measured and thought-provoking.

More Than Just True Crime

While “The Velvet Hammer” certainly delivers on its promise of gritty true crime content, it’s Perry’s reflections on the broader issues of justice, race, and morality that elevate this memoir above the typical genre fare. His discussions on the evolution of Florida’s domestic violence laws in the wake of tragic cases like that of Karen Spencer are particularly enlightening.

Perry’s writing style, likely shaped by his years of crafting legal opinions, is clear and direct. There’s a no-nonsense quality to his prose that befits his reputation as a tough but fair judge. That said, moments of unexpected humor and vulnerability shine through, humanizing the man behind the robe.

A Southern Perspective on Justice

Throughout the book, Perry’s Southern roots are evident. His colloquialisms lend an authentic flavor to the narrative. When describing particularly gruesome crime scenes or difficult decisions, you can almost hear the slow, deliberate drawl of a man carefully weighing his words.

One particularly affecting passage comes when Perry recalls sitting in the electric chair during a visit to death row with his law clerks:

“During one visit to the prison, I sat in the electric chair. That wooden chair with electrodes reinforced the seriousness of a death sentence, the sacred obligation of being a judge and the oath I took. As a capital murder judge, I was given the power to start the mechanism of death….

 

…I needed to dot all the i’s and cross all the t’s to ensure my sentences were proper for the crimes committed and the defendants I sentenced to death were fairly judged. When I stood up and walked away from that electric chair, I realized being a judge was a lonely walk. “

The Scales of Justice: Weighing the Book’s Merits

Perry and Mitchell have crafted a compelling narrative that manages to be both informative and emotionally resonant. True crime aficionados will appreciate the behind-the-scenes details of high-profile cases, while those interested in the broader workings of the American justice system will find much to ponder.

Verdict: A Must-Read for True Crime Enthusiasts

In the crowded field of true crime literature, “The Velvet Hammer” stands out as a uniquely authoritative and multifaceted work. It’s not just a recitation of gruesome crimes, but a thoughtful examination of justice, morality, and the human experience from a man who has seen the best and worst of humanity.

Perry’s journey from a segregated childhood to the pinnacle of the Florida judicial system is inspiring, and his candid reflections on the weighty responsibilities of his position are deeply moving. Whether you’re a longtime follower of high-profile criminal cases or simply curious about the inner workings of the American legal system, “The Velvet Hammer” offers a compelling and enlightening read.

Highlights:

• Insider perspective on infamous cases like Casey Anthony and Judy Buenoano
• Thoughtful examination of capital punishment and its moral implications
• Unique blend of true crime, memoir, and legal analysis
• Authentic Southern voice brings the Florida courtroom to life

Who Should Read This Book:

• True crime enthusiasts
• Legal professionals and law students
• Those interested in social justice and race relations in America
• Anyone fascinated by high-profile criminal cases

Similar Books:

While “The Velvet Hammer” is Perry’s debut memoir, readers interested in similar perspectives from the bench might enjoy:

• “Scalia Speaks: Reflections on Law, Faith, and Life Well Lived” by Antonin Scalia
• “My Grandfather’s Son: A Memoir” by Clarence Thomas
• “Just Mercy: A Story of Justice and Redemption” by Bryan Stevenson

Final Thoughts

“The Velvet Hammer” is more than just another true crime book. It’s a deeply personal account of one man’s quest for justice in a complex and often brutal world. Perry’s unique perspective as both a trailblazing African American jurist and a key player in some of Florida’s most notorious criminal cases makes for a fascinating read.

As Perry himself might say, “Y’all, this ain’t just about the gory details of murder cases. It’s about the hard work of justice, the weight of making life-or-death decisions, and the never-ending struggle to do what’s right in a world that ain’t always black and white.”

In the end, “The Velvet Hammer” serves as both a gripping true crime narrative and a thought-provoking meditation on justice, race, and morality in America. It’s a book that will stay with you long after you’ve turned the final page, leaving you with a deeper appreciation for the complexities of our legal system and the dedicated individuals who strive to make it work.

So go on, pick up a copy of “The Velvet Hammer.” Just don’t be surprised if you find yourself staying up way past your bedtime, turning pages faster than a Florida gator can snap its jaws. This is one legal thriller that’s all too real, and all the more fascinating for it.