Adriana Trigiani returns with The View From Lake Como, a story that reads like a love letter to both the Italian-American experience and the transformative power of creative courage. In this latest offering, Trigiani weaves together family secrets, artistic awakening, and the eternal pull of ancestral homelands with the same warmth and authenticity that has made her a beloved voice in contemporary women’s fiction.
The novel follows Jess Capodimonte Baratta, a thirty-four-year-old woman whose life has become as fragmented as broken marble. Recently divorced from Bobby Bilancia—described with tongue-in-cheek humor as “the perfect husband”—Jess finds herself living in her parents’ basement in Lake Como, New Jersey, a town that shares its name with the famous Italian destination but little else. This geographical irony sets the tone for a story about finding beauty and possibility in unexpected places.
A Protagonist Worth Rooting For
Trigiani’s greatest strength lies in creating protagonists who feel authentically flawed yet inherently worthy of our investment. Jess embodies the overlooked daughter archetype with genuine poignancy—she’s the family caretaker, the Sunday dinner coordinator, the one who puts everyone else’s needs before her own. Yet beneath this familiar exterior lies a talented draftswoman working in her Uncle Louie’s marble business, a detail that proves crucial to both plot and character development.
The author’s portrayal of Jess’s emotional journey feels particularly authentic when she writes: “I am not living the life of my dreams. Not even close.” This simple statement carries the weight of countless compromises and deferred dreams that many readers will recognize in their own lives. Trigiani doesn’t romanticize depression or divorce; instead, she presents them as starting points for transformation rather than endpoints.
Uncle Louie Capodimonte emerges as more than just a plot device—he’s Jess’s confidant, mentor, and the keeper of family secrets that will ultimately shatter everything she thought she knew. His death early in the novel doesn’t diminish his presence; rather, it amplifies throughout the story through FBI investigations into his offshore accounts and the revelation of a son he never knew existed in Italy.
The Dual Settings: New Jersey Grit Meets Italian Grace
Trigiani demonstrates her mastery of setting by creating two equally vivid worlds. Lake Como, New Jersey, pulses with blue-collar authenticity—a place where “family comes first” isn’t just a saying but a governing principle that can either nurture or suffocate. The author captures the claustrophobic comfort of tight-knit Italian-American communities with both affection and clear-eyed observation.
When Jess escapes to Carrara, Italy, the prose transforms along with her circumstances. Trigiani’s descriptions of the marble-capped mountains of Tuscany and the ancient piazzas feel lived-in rather than tourist-brochure pretty. The transition from the metaphorical basement of her New Jersey life to the sun-drenched terraces of Italy mirrors Jess’s internal journey from passive acceptance to active pursuit of her dreams.
The author’s own Italian heritage shines through in her portrayal of Carrara, particularly in scenes at the marble quarries where Michelangelo once sourced his stone. These passages achieve genuine beauty without slipping into overwrought romanticism:
“The town square is empty, making it easy to see the artful pattern of the inlaid stonework that extends to the edge of the piazza.”
Romance That Feels Earned Rather Than Expected
Angelo Strazza, the passionate gold artist who becomes Jess’s love interest, could easily have fallen into the “mysterious Italian lover” stereotype. Trigiani avoids this trap by giving him genuine depth and complexity. His initial relationship with Dalia and daughter Alice prevents him from being simply available for Jess’s convenience. Their romance develops organically through shared artistic appreciation and genuine emotional connection rather than mere geographical proximity.
The tension between Angelo and Bobby Bilancia during their unexpected encounter feels authentic to the messy reality of moving forward while still processing the past. Trigiani handles this love triangle—if it can be called that—with maturity, avoiding melodrama in favor of honest emotional complexity.
Family Secrets and FBI Investigations: Plot Threads That Strengthen Rather Than Tangle
The revelation of Uncle Louie’s secret business dealings—the aptly named “Elegant Gangster”—could have derailed the story into thriller territory. Instead, Trigiani uses these complications to deepen Jess’s character development. Her cooperation with the FBI investigation demonstrates her moral compass while the offshore accounts serve as a bridge between her New Jersey past and Italian future.
The discovery of Mauro LaFortezza as Uncle Louie’s unknown son adds emotional weight without feeling contrived. This plot development forces Jess to grapple with questions about truth, family loyalty, and the weight of secrets—themes that resonate throughout the novel.
Therapeutic Threads: Mental Health with Authenticity
Trigiani deserves particular praise for her portrayal of Jess’s online therapy through the Thera-Me app. Rather than treating mental health as a quick fix or easy resolution, the author presents therapy as ongoing work. The rotating therapists—Dr. Sharon, Dr. Raymond, Dr. Rex, and others—each contribute different perspectives to Jess’s journey.
The therapy sessions feel authentic rather than preachy, with exercises like the “dream board” and family analysis that many readers will recognize from their own experiences. Jess’s gradual growth feels earned rather than sudden, reflecting the reality of therapeutic progress.
Where the Story Stumbles
While The View From Lake Como succeeds on multiple levels, it occasionally suffers from pacing issues in the middle section. Jess’s adjustment to life in Carrara sometimes feels rushed, particularly her rapid integration into the artistic community. Some readers may find the resolution of the FBI investigation too convenient, though the emotional payoff justifies the neat conclusion.
The supporting characters in Italy, while charming, don’t always achieve the same depth as their New Jersey counterparts. Signora Strazza’s anxiety attacks and family dynamics feel somewhat underdeveloped compared to the rich portrayal of Jess’s immediate family.
Themes That Resonate Beyond Romance
Trigiani explores several themes that elevate this beyond simple romance or women’s fiction:
- Creative Fulfillment vs. Financial Security: Jess’s journey from draftswoman to artist reflects broader questions about pursuing passion over practicality.
- Cultural Identity: The tension between Italian-American heritage and actual Italian experience provides rich material for examination.
- Family Obligation vs. Personal Dreams: The author navigates this classic conflict with nuance, suggesting that honoring family doesn’t require sacrificing individual aspirations.
- Truth and Secrets: The novel questions whether protecting people from painful truths serves them or merely serves our own comfort.
A Satisfying Entry in Trigiani’s Canon
Readers familiar with Trigiani’s previous works—from the Big Stone Gap series to The Shoemaker’s Wife—will recognize her signature blend of family saga, romance, and cultural exploration. The View From Lake Como feels like a natural evolution of her storytelling, maintaining the warmth and humor that characterize her best work while tackling more complex emotional territory.
The novel’s resolution feels satisfying without being overly tidy. Jess’s transformation from passive observer to active participant in her own life provides genuine character growth, while the romantic elements complement rather than overshadow her personal journey.
Final Verdict: A Story Worth Savoring
The View From Lake Como succeeds as both escapist fiction and meaningful exploration of family, identity, and creative courage. Trigiani’s authentic voice and genuine affection for her characters overcome occasional pacing issues and plot conveniences.
This novel will particularly appeal to readers who enjoyed Eat, Pray, Love or Under the Tuscan Sun, but with more emotional depth and less idealization of Italian life. It’s a story about second chances, family complications, and the courage required to rebuild a life from scratch—themes that feel especially relevant in our current cultural moment.
For fans of women’s fiction that doesn’t shy away from complex family dynamics or the messiness of real emotional growth, The View From Lake Como offers both satisfaction and substance. Trigiani proves once again why she remains a trusted voice for readers seeking stories that honor both the heart and the mind.
Similar Reads You’ll Enjoy
If The View From Lake Como resonated with you, consider these comparable novels:
- The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo by Taylor Jenkins Reid – For family secrets and reinvention
- Beautiful Ruins by Jess Walter – For Italian settings and romantic complexity
- The Light We Lost by Jill Santopolo – For second chances at love
- My Education by Susan Choi – For stories of self-discovery
- The Storied Life of A.J. Fikry by Gabrielle Zevin – For small-town charm and new beginnings
- The Midnight Library by Matt Haig – For themes of life choices and alternate paths
- Beach Read by Emily Henry – For romance with emotional depth
- The Ten Thousand Doors of January by Alix E. Harrow – For magical realism and family mysteries
The View From Lake Como reminds us that sometimes the most beautiful views come after the steepest climbs—and that home isn’t always the place where you started, but the place where you finally choose to grow.
