In her gripping debut novel Shutter, Ramona Emerson masterfully weaves together supernatural horror, crime thriller, and Native American storytelling traditions. The result is a unique narrative that explores the space between traditional Navajo beliefs and contemporary police work through the eyes of Rita Todacheene, a forensic photographer who sees the ghosts of murder victims.
The Heart of the Story
Rita Todacheene’s gift – or curse – of seeing spirits has shaped her entire life, from her childhood on the Navajo reservation to her current role as a forensic photographer for the Albuquerque Police Department. When the angry ghost of Erma Singleton, a supposed suicide victim, attaches itself to Rita, she’s drawn into a dangerous web of cartel violence, police corruption, and revenge that threatens everything she holds dear.
Writing Style & Atmosphere
Emerson’s prose is atmospheric and visceral, particularly in scenes involving Rita’s photography work. The author’s background in filmmaking shines through in her vivid visual descriptions and careful attention to detail. Each chapter is named after a different camera or photographic technique, creating a unique structural element that reinforces the protagonist’s connection to photography.
Strengths
- Rich cultural authenticity in portraying Navajo traditions and beliefs
- Expertly crafted tension between supernatural and procedural elements
- Strong character development, especially in flashback sequences
- Vivid, cinematic descriptions of crime scenes and supernatural encounters
- Complex exploration of family relationships and cultural identity
Areas for Improvement
- Pacing occasionally slows in the middle sections
- Some secondary characters could be more fully developed
- The supernatural rules governing ghost interactions aren’t always clearly defined
- A few plot threads feel slightly unresolved
Character Analysis
Rita Todacheene emerges as a compelling and complex protagonist, struggling to balance her traditional upbringing with her modern life. Her relationship with her grandmother serves as the emotional anchor of the story, while her interactions with ghosts provide both supernatural tension and deeper character insights.
The supporting cast is generally well-drawn, particularly:
- Grandma Todacheene: A strong traditional figure who grounds the narrative
- Mr. Bitsilly: The medicine man who helps Rita understand her gift
- Detective Garcia: A corrupt cop whose actions drive much of the plot
- Erma Singleton: The vengeful ghost whose case becomes central to the story
Cultural Context & Themes
Emerson skillfully integrates Navajo cultural elements without falling into stereotypes or over-explanation. The novel explores several compelling themes:
- The tension between traditional beliefs and modern life
- The weight of family obligations and cultural heritage
- The cost of having abilities others don’t understand
- The complex relationship between law enforcement and Native communities
- The nature of justice and revenge
Impact and Series Potential
Shutter is the first book in the Rita Todacheene series by Ramona Emerson, with Exposure announced as the upcoming sequel. The strong world-building and character development in this debut suggest promising potential for the series’ continuation.
Technical Elements
The author’s attention to detail regarding forensic photography and police procedure lends authenticity to the narrative. The integration of camera terminology and photographic concepts adds depth to the story without becoming overwhelming for readers unfamiliar with photography.
Comparative Analysis
While Shutter by Ramona Emerson shares elements with other supernatural crime novels, its unique blend of Navajo culture and forensic detail sets it apart. Fans of Craig Johnson’s Longmire series or Tony Hillerman’s Leaphorn & Chee novels will find familiar territory here, but with a fresh supernatural twist and contemporary perspective.
Critical Reception
The novel has received generally positive reviews, with particular praise for:
- Authentic representation of Navajo culture
- Fresh take on the supernatural crime genre
- Strong sense of place and atmosphere
- Complex female protagonist
Final Verdict
Shutter is a wonderful paranormal thriller, marking Ramona Emerson as an exciting new voice in supernatural crime fiction. While there are some minor pacing issues and occasionally underdeveloped plot elements, the novel’s strengths far outweigh its weaknesses.
Recommended for readers who enjoy:
- Supernatural crime thrillers
- Native American fiction
- Police procedurals with a twist
- Character-driven mysteries
- Stories about cultural identity
Looking Forward
With Exposure on the horizon, readers can look forward to further exploring Rita’s world and abilities. The groundwork laid in Shutter suggests that future installments will continue to blend supernatural elements with crime investigation while delving deeper into Navajo culture and tradition.
The Rita Todacheene series has the potential to carve out its own unique space in the supernatural crime genre, offering readers a fresh perspective on both forensic investigation and Native American storytelling traditions.