In her latest novel, Asia Mackay delivers a refreshingly original take on the domestic thriller genre, blending dark humor with sharp social commentary. A Serial Killer’s Guide to Marriage is a deliciously twisted tale that asks: what happens when serial killers try to settle down in suburbia?
Plot Overview
Hazel and Fox are the perfect power couple—sophisticated, successful, and secretly serial killers who target deserving bad men. Their carefully choreographed life of glamour and vigilante justice comes to a halt when Hazel becomes pregnant. Fast forward two years, and they’re living in an upscale gated community, attending mommy-and-me music classes, and trying to embrace suburban domesticity. While Fox thrives in his new role as a devoted father, Hazel struggles with the mundane reality of motherhood and desperately misses the thrill of the kill.
When Hazel breaks their pact by murdering someone without Fox’s knowledge, their carefully constructed facade begins to crack. The situation becomes even more complicated when Hazel befriends Jenny, a police detective on maternity leave who starts piecing together connections to their past crimes.
Writing Style
Mackay’s prose is sharp, witty, and delightfully sardonic. She masterfully balances dark subject matter with humor, creating a narrative voice that is both engaging and unsettling. The author particularly excels at:
- Crafting razor-sharp dialogue
- Building tension through alternating perspectives
- Using dark humor to explore serious themes
- Creating vivid, memorable characters
Character Development
The character work in this novel is exceptional, particularly in its portrayal of Hazel. Her struggle with postpartum identity crisis is portrayed with surprising depth and nuance, even as she maintains her murderous tendencies. The complexity of her character—loving mother, devoted wife, and unrepentant killer—makes her a fascinating protagonist.
Fox’s evolution from methodical killer to suburban dad is equally well-drawn, showing how his obsessive planning nature adapts to parenthood. The dynamic between Hazel and Fox feels authentic, their relationship built on a foundation of shared secrets and genuine understanding.
Thematic Depth
The novel explores several interconnected themes:
- The challenges of maintaining identity after parenthood
- Marriage and the secrets we keep from our partners
- The contrast between surface appearances and hidden realities
- Female rage and societal expectations
- The complexity of female friendship
Social Commentary
Mackay delivers biting commentary on suburban life and motherhood without ever becoming preachy. Her observations about the competitive nature of modern parenting and the suffocating expectations placed on mothers are particularly sharp. The author uses her protagonists’ unusual perspective to highlight the absurdities of “normal” society.
Strengths
The novel’s greatest achievement is how it manages to make its murderous protagonists sympathetic while never downplaying their actions. The balance between domestic drama and thriller elements is masterfully handled, creating a unique hybrid that defies easy categorization.
The friendship between Hazel and Jenny adds an unexpected layer of emotional depth to the story, exploring themes of trust, betrayal, and the complicated nature of female relationships.
Areas for Improvement
While generally well-paced, the novel occasionally struggles with tonal shifts between its darker elements and domestic comedy. Some readers might find it challenging to empathize with characters who, despite their charm, are unrepentant killers.
Comparison to Other Works
Fans of Dexter Morgan’s dark humor or You’s Joe Goldberg’s twisted perspective will find familiar elements here, though Mackay’s approach is distinctly feminine and far more satirical. The novel also shares DNA with domestic thrillers like Gone Girl, but subverts many of the genre’s traditional tropes.
Technical Execution
Mackay demonstrates impressive skill in:
- Maintaining suspense across multiple timelines
- Balancing multiple plot threads
- Creating distinctive voices for different characters
- Building and releasing tension effectively
Cultural Impact
The novel offers a fresh perspective on several contemporary issues:
- The pressures of modern parenthood
- Gender roles in marriage
- The isolation of suburban life
- Female anger and its expression
- The complexity of maintaining friendships as adults
Style and Structure
The book’s structure, alternating between past and present, effectively builds tension while revealing the history of Hazel and Fox’s relationship. Mackay’s use of dark humor serves both to entertain and to make deeper points about society’s expectations of women and mothers.
Final Assessment
A Serial Killer’s Guide to Marriage is a bold, original novel that succeeds on multiple levels. It works as a thriller, as domestic satire, and as a surprisingly thoughtful examination of marriage and parenthood. While some readers might struggle with its darker elements, those willing to embrace its unique premise will find a smart, entertaining, and occasionally profound reading experience.
Recommended for:
- Fans of dark comedy and psychological thrillers
- Readers who enjoy subversive takes on domestic life
- Those who appreciate complex female protagonists
- Anyone looking for a fresh perspective on marriage and parenthood
- Readers who don’t mind their humor pitch-black
Final Thoughts
This novel represents a significant evolution in Mackay’s work, building on the strengths shown in her previous novels while pushing into new territory. It’s a daring blend of genres that somehow works, delivering both thrills and insights into modern marriage and parenthood.
A Serial Killer’s Guide to Marriage is that rare thing – a genuinely original voice in a crowded genre. While it may not be for everyone, readers who appreciate its unique blend of darkness and wit will find themselves thoroughly entertained and occasionally enlightened.